• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

New York Pizzeria - Waterville: Authentic New York-Style Pizza & Friendly Service in Waterville, NY

New York Pizzeria - Waterville, located at 111 W Main St, delivers authentic, generously topped New York-style pizza that keeps locals and visitors coming back. Known for their fresh, crisp crusts and flavorful slices, this pizzeria offers more than just pizza—wings cooked to perfection and satisfying subs complete the menu. The warm, personal service from owners and staff creates a welcoming small-town atmosphere, even during busy hours. Customers praise the consistent quality and attention to detail, like customizing extra sauce on half a pie. It’s a standout spot where hearty portions and genuine hospitality blend seamlessly, making every visit a rewarding experience.

New York Pizzeria - Waterville at a glance

  • Address 111 W Main St, Waterville, NY 13480, United States
  • Phone +1 315-841-8898
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Fast food restaurant , Restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

New York Pizzeria - Waterville: Reviews & Ratings

Douglas Seitz
5

Had some of the best food was really good I'll be going there from now on

Aaron Strong
5

We moved to the area about a year ago and tried out a few of the local pizza places. After a lot of not so good pizza, finally found NY Pizzeria in Waterville. It is consistently excellent. Toppings are generous. Food is yummy! Service is small town great! Service is personal and outstanding, whether it's the owners or the staff. This place is always slammed, yet they are happy to greet you, politely take payment, and say good bye when you leave. Yesterday I ordered a pizza with extra sauce on one half. My crazy aunt likes lots of sauce! They mentioned adding it on the side, so I went with a whole pizza with sauce. Then, I got there. The owner showed me how I could tell which side had the extra sauce. They did it! Half extra, half regular. We've had multiple subs, appetizers, slices, garlic knots, and whole pizzas. Everything is always consistently yummy. I don't know they do it, given how busy this place is. Their systems work! These people are the best! I hope to come back to this place for years!

Matt P
5

I was driving through Waterville and noticed this pizzeria. Stopped in for a slice and it was very very good. I was greeted instantly by the pizza maker and my slice was more than perfect. I will definitely stop back again on my next time through Waterville

A. LeDuc
4

Pizza was a little pricey for cheese pizzas, but a good flavor, tried here because my normal spot was on vacation (slices). Hot fresh pizza, great crust. They were busy and seemed a bit tested but a good family atmosphere other wise. Would be my 2nd option if needed one close to my home town.

Julianne Burchill
5

Best place around this area. Wings are cooked to perfection with just the right amount of sauce. And the pizza is loaded!! You definitely get your money's worth. Plus you walk in and everyone is always so nice and working so hard.

Jessica(info) Miracle
5

This may just be the best pizza I've ever had and for a ridiculously low price. We got 2 slices of pizza, 2 meatball sliders, and 2 drinks for right around $18. We were both stuffed. The service was great. The atmosphere is cheesy, but in the best way possible. We are visiting from Colorado and this was a surprise I was not expecting!! Highly recommend!!

Joe L
5

Excellent pizza and cooked perfectly. Sauce has a great flavor profile. Crust was spot on also Great friendly service at this rustic pizza joint.

Location

  • New York Pizzeria - Waterville
    New York Pizzeria - Waterville
    111 W Main St, Waterville, NY 13480, United States Hotline: +1 315-841-8898

New York Pizzeria - Waterville, located at 111 W Main St, Waterville, NY, stands out as a true gem for pizza lovers seeking authentic New York-style flavors in a welcoming small-town atmosphere. From the moment you step inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked crusts and generous toppings sets the stage for a memorable meal. The pizza here strikes a perfect balance between a crisp, tasty crust and vibrant, well-balanced sauces that enhance each bite without overpowering the natural flavors.

The menu offers a variety of standout options—whether it’s the Plain Cheese Pizza, rich and gooey with just the right amount of melted cheese, or the loaded Meat Lovers and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizzas, which bring hearty, satisfying layers of flavor. The Chicken Alfredo pizza is a creamy, indulgent twist that showcases their ability to blend traditional and inventive toppings seamlessly. For those seeking something beyond pizza, the Fish Fry and Philly Cheese Steak Subs deliver comfort and quality, while the Antipasto Salad and Calzones provide fresh, lighter options without sacrificing taste.

What truly sets New York Pizzeria apart is the consistency and care reflected in every dish. Generous portions, fresh ingredients, and clear attention to detail—such as customizing sauce amounts exactly as requested—reflect a dedication that is affirmed by patrons like Aaron Strong and Julianne Burchill, who praise not only the food but also the friendly, personalized service. Even on busy days, the staff remains attentive and warm, elevating the dining experience into something more personal and inviting than your average pizza joint.

Having sampled a variety of dishes here, from the cheese fries to the flavorful Hawaiian Pizza, I am consistently impressed by the quality and flavor profiles that feel both authentic to New York pizzerias and uniquely cared for by this local establishment. Whether you are a local or just passing through Waterville, New York Pizzeria offers a satisfying, delicious escape where comfort food meets genuine hospitality.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards